Debunking the Teleprompter Meme

Ta-Nehisi Coates and Jonathan Chait expanded on something we’ve discussed at length here. The Republicans are using the Teleprompter meme as a way to paint arguably the most intelligent and well-spoken presidents in modern history as a mumbling doofus.

Here’s why. First, it’s Southern Strategy politics. They’re telegraphing to their white base that black people are stupids and shouldn’t hold the office. Second, they’re attacking the president’s primary strength: his intelligence and oratorical skills. Third, it’s payback for eight years of Bushisms.

Of course none of it holds up because everyone uses Teleprompters, from news anchors to sportscasters to cable news talkers to presidents, and, more importantly, there’s a considerable record of the president speaking extemporaneously and doing so with thoughtfulness and insight, qualities that our previous president lacked completely. Coates also pointed to this video as further evidence:

Print Friendly
This entry was posted in Republican Party and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://twitter.com/Pen_Bird Phlip

    “This eloquence…” –John McCain, referring to Obama’s performance in the debates, without a teleprompter.

    And “payback for 8 years of Bushisms” is spot-on. Who can forget Bush reading a teleprompter, obviously stoned on pills, obviously not understanding a word he was reading, in a fake Texas accent. “Projectivity” is indeed a clinical symptom of the Authoritarian Personality Syndrome…

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SBL64RBDUTDTYXXDUNRMCUW2XY MaikeH

      “in a fake Texas accent” — LOL, so true. W started talking that way when he began his run for president and assumed a “cowboy” persona.

  • http://twitter.com/KQuark KQµårk™

    Ding, Ding correct on all of the above.

    Moreover teleprompters denote progress and we know Republicans hate progress.

    Think of the alternative.

    Do we really want our president wasting their valuable time trying to memorize a speech?

    Or you can be like Gingrich and use the 1970′s teleprompter aka flash cards.

    Then the worse are candidates rambling on like Santorum or Paul.

  • http://twitter.com/tifosies tifosies

    Mitt has already used it, at least New Hampshire, maybe in Florida…ahhhh sweet justice :)

  • muselet

    What seems to enrage Rs about Barack Obama is less that he’s eloquent and more that he speaks like—surprise, surprise—an academic. Lots of professorial types have the same traits: false starts to sentences early in a complicated statement, hesitations while searching for the exact words required, speaking relatively dispassionately.

    There was an article in the LA Dog Trainer some months ago—which I don’t have the time or energy to try to find (sorry)—about Obama’s speaking style, which quoted a rank-and-file–type Republican saying that Sarah Palin (so hated and feared by the lamestream media!) was a model of clarity, while Obama could barely string words together into recognizable sentences with all those pauses and “um”s.

    The business about prompters builds on that idiocy. It helps the Rs that maybe 1% of the population knows what a teleprompter is or does; Rs seem to fantasize that a (presumably white male) speechwriter somewhere (maybe that’s what one of those wooden boxes under the teleprompters is for!) is typing madly while the president speaks so he doesn’t start rapping “Cop Killer” or choke on his tongue.

    This is what happens when a political party is able to create its own pocket universe.

    –alopecia

    • stacib23

      I saw a clip of Ronald Reagan yesterday using a goddam teleprompter. Flippin’ 30 years ago. Maybe “they” don’t understand that it didn’t begin with Obama.

      • muselet

        The brighter Rs do understand. They know the meme is codswallop, but they’re happy to sell it to the dumber members of the tribe.

        –alopecia

    • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SBL64RBDUTDTYXXDUNRMCUW2XY MaikeH

      “Rs seem to fantasize that a (presumably white male) speechwriter somewhere (maybe that’s what one of those wooden boxes under the teleprompters is for!) is typing madly while the president speaks so he doesn’t start rapping “Cop Killer” or choke on his tongue.”

      That’s exactly it. In the wingnut alternate universe, the “Kenyan usurper” must have had professors who “changed his grades,” a ghost writer for his books (Bill Ayres), and a fast typist feeding him lines through a teleprompter. The concept of an intelligent black man is inconceivable to them.

      • muselet

        The concept of an intelligent black man is inconceivable to them.

        True for values of black man = Democrat.

        –alopecia

  • Terri S

    Ahh, watching that makes me savor just the thought of the President facing whoever ends up as the Republican nominee in debates.

  • ArrogantDemon

    He didnt need no damn teleprompter for this ass whooping

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5vOMIN673A

    Let them comfort themselves some more, then when the real deal comes and tears into Mittens like a slab of baby back ribs, let the horror sink in as the color fades from their face in sick recoil…….

    Soon……..sooon

  • txvoodoo

    Man, this whole segment of that debate could be used as a campaign ad for Obama 2012 – it validates his approach.

  • txvoodoo

    Spot on. In my view, it’s far better to consider your words carefully. But Rs seem to like it when candidates just spit out words without hesitation, no matter if they make sense or not.

  • villemar

    The thing I’ve noticed about these inbreds is that they are engaging in classic Freudian projection. The thing about Freud’s theories is that no one really uses them anymore because although it was a starting point it was horribly reductionist. Most rational, developed adults can’t be pigeonholed into a Freudian model. But the funny thing I’ve noticed is that when you’re dealing with an angry bucktoothed Republican? Oh hell to the yeah! Those theories start to work again, because you are dealing with someone who only utilizes the lizard part of their brain. So even though it’s pretty antiquated for the majority of adults….dust off those 100 year tomes if you want to put these people on the couch. “Duh you’re a gay retard!!1!! Why do you hate America????” See?

  • http://www.osborneink.com OsborneInk

    Bill-O uses a teleprompter.

    • http://www.politicalruminations.com/ nicole

      They ALL use teleprompters. :)

      Bunch of damn dumb stupids is what they are.

  • http://www.politicalruminations.com/ nicole

    Best example of what the Pres can do to Repubs without a teleprompter was when he faced the R idiots in Congress, and proceeded to kick their asses for 90 or so minutes at what was supposed to be their own little smackdown.

    The man is brilliant. But he could be Jesus Christ himself and the Republicans would still hate and revile him for his skin color alone.